"Ever since the first computers, there have always been ghosts in the machine. Random segments of code that have grouped together to form unexpected protocol. One we call behavior, unanticipated." -Dr. Alfred Lanning, "I, Robot" (2004)
Saturday, October 04, 2008
Phoenix Wright (for all the Wrong Reasons)
Did I mention that the cases are universally murders? They are. The court system you must wade through is some ill-defined parody of judicial proceedings. There is almost no sharing of information, the defense must do its own detective work, the prosecution's only goal is the conviction of the suspect, and innocence must be proven beyond a shadow of a doubt. Justice is also very swift in this hybrid American-Japanese land, often only taking a few days from slaughter to sentence.
The game consists of four cases and breaks down into two gameplay sections encoutnered in each: detective work and courtroom drama. Law & Order, without Jerry Orbach... or sanity. Detective work has you exploring locations related to the crime, and talking to anyone who might have information. In each area you are given the option to examine your surroundings. Sometimes, after gaining certain conversational tidbits, you gain important clues or evidence. Each person has certain limited topics they'll converse on, sometimes they'll reveal more, sometimes they'll be Psyche-Locked. I'll get to that in a minute. You can also show them evidence you've collected or people you've encountered. They might have some flavour comment, sometimes it'll lead to more conversation or a clue, often they'll rattle off a generic response. Most of what you have to do is collect enough evidence to break through the Psyche-Locks that are preventing you from learning the secrets that will blow the case wide open.
After your detective work is done, you spend a day in court. This has three parts: reading a lot of conversational text, cross-examining testimonies, and making crucial descisions. Most of the time you have to find the lie or contradiction in the testimony just presented. You can press for more information on each statement, and present evidence to contradict and confound. Do your job right and the truth will evntually come to light. Make the wrong choice or present the wrong evidence and you'll receive a pentalty. Sometimes you'll get to do more detective work, but the end of each case always comes from a verdict.
Enough of trying to describe the ideosyncratic Japanese-style adventure gameplay. What I really wanted to talk about is how Phoenix Wright is both great fun while being a horrible game. Like most of the plots and logic in the game, this is a huge contradiction and doesn't make much sense. Nevertheless, I'd like to examine the evidence.
What Makes Phoenix Wright Great
There is actually only one thing that makes this game worthwhile: the writing. That's okay though, because there's only one thing that makes it awful; it's a fairly shallow game. The game is nicely drawn, and has some funny animations, but most of it will get old the 50th time you see it. Visually the game is pretty but static, and the graphics tend to do little to draw you in. They are mearly window dressing for the real meat of the game; the clever writing. By which I don't mean story or plot. Most of that is pretty thin. Chances are that you'll have figured out the twist a good while before anyone else does. However, the game does two things extremely well when it comes to the writing: character and pacing.
The cast is a varied, quirky, and lovable bunch. Many of them carry over from the first game, and some of the subtext is carry over as well. The dialog and internal monologues spend a lot of time examining relationships, and exploring how people connect. That extends from the suspects and witnesses to the core cast. It brings them to life and, like any good melodrama, makes you care about them. Then, when they are inevitably in peril, you are hooked into seeing it through to a happy end. The translators have also done a fantasitc job of replacing Japanese pop-cultre references with american ones, giving the game's humour a tuned-in geek flavour.
All of which is heightened by the incredibly tight pacing. The main gameplay flaws that I'll get to in a moment facilitate the precise timing of details and reveals. Everything happens just as it needs to, twisting unexpectedly and turning around in an instant. Feelings of anticipation and suspense are created at crucial times. The game speeds up and slows down in cycles, and manages to get climactic without feeling abrupt. Between the twin hooks of character and pacing, the game manages to draw you in and then pull you along to the conclusion, despite its flaws.
What Makes Phoenix Wright Awful
The problem with this game is that there isn't a game to speak of. The mechanics are present, and are used by the designers to ensure that the game blocks and procedes as intended. What they don't do is provide any sense of agency. The game does two things to advertise an open experience, but deny it in actuality: the free exploration is carefully locked down, and the meaningful choices aren't meaningful.
The first happens during the detective phases, as you wander from place to place. You are given the freedom to roam from place to place, sometime with multiple people to talk to at once. Despite that, there are things that must be done and people that must be talked to in a certain order to procede. Too obviously, you run into roadblocks intended to prevent progress until some other unspoken criteria has been met. More than just talking to someone to open a new area, or finding a new clue to open new avenues of discussion. Often you will have to talk to someone about a specific object before their converstation is truly complete, without indication of what. Flipping this flag will then re-arrange where people are or make new people available in old locations, stepping the story along one notch. It becomes very obvious that progress is meted out in tightly controlled chunks. Want to solve the mystery your own way? Not going to happen.
The second blow comes during the courtroom phases. These sections of the story are necessarily linear. The prosecution calls witnesses, gets testimony, then you cross examine. The bulk of the story is driven by the plot, and the opposing characters. Your goal is to expand, deduce, and present the contradictions and lies to the court. Often Phoenix is given a choice, some answer he must give or crucial descision he must make. Sometimes making the wrong one costs him a penalty. Lose too much and you lose the case. This happens a lot when you need to present evidence but can't figure out exactly what the game is looking for. That's not my complaint.
It's the little choices you are asked to make, often with a threat of pentaly, that turn out not to matter. You are initially led to believe that what you choose matters. Truth is, that often it doesn't. Pick either one and the same results unfold. It's false agency, and once you know it's there it becomes hard to ignore. You have to treat every descision as life or death because of the threat, but you can't because you know that the results will often be whatever the designers have predetermined is best. Then, when you choose wrong you are hit with a needless hinderance. These do-or-die penalties for not understanding the game-logic, or making a connection in the wrong place or at the wring time are screen smashingly frustrating, and do nothing to help the game.
Justice for Some
This game isn't for everyone. It's a bizzaro-world courtroom melodrama with manga sensibilities. It could have been a Saturday morning cartoon. You never really get to be Phoenix Wright anyway. The persona is too strong to be an effective avatar. You're more like his inspiration. Pointing him in the right direction, giving him the nudge he needs to make the puzzle fall into place. However, once started, it is hard to quit. If you drop your guard enough to let the characters in, and let the subtle pop-humour amuse you, you'll find yourself hooked until the end. Just have a guide ready. I recommend the Universal Hints System. Don't be ashamed, you'll only be playing it for the story and the characters anyway.
Wednesday, April 02, 2008
Captain McGrandpa
I missed the actual game, and I'm kind of sorry I did. It looks like it was fun to play.
Organized and run by GameTap staff member TheRedEye, Captain McGrandpa really was a multiplayer adventure game. Hearkening back to the text adventures of old, TheRedEye narrated a real-time story. Over the period of 8 hours the forum members posted commands and he would use those commands to write the next part of the game/story.
You can read through the game log here (at least for now).
And you can read the Postmortem here.
I encourage you to take a little time, if you have it, to read through how the game went. It was rather interesting. He started the game with only a rough outline of starting areas and characters. The rest of the game, including the ending, was improvised as users provided commands. This did make advancing the game a little difficult, but fortunately he was able to see his way through.
Now, I'm not suggesting that improvisation was bad. In fact, just the opposite, I think it was the key to the game's success. But early on, I did feel the pressures of the game not having a definitive end. Fortunately, about halfway through, I saw a clear path toward the game's solution, which was inspired by items and situations created on-the-fly by our users. I promised that the users would shape the world around them in real-time, and that was accurate.What I find most interesting is the community's initial reactions, and how they were able to get somewhat organized over time. Being put forward as an April Fool's joke I think had some initial detrimental effects, as people probably dismissed it as a gag and didn't realize that there was actually a heartfelt attempt to create a story going on. This raised a little bit of disdain from some people hoping to replace their dying Uru. However, some people ran with the gag and began to explore the story offered to them.
This led to more people realizing that they really were exploring something, and affecting how the story was turning out. Once that happened, you can see that more people start jumping in with commands and a little bit of confusion and argument crops up about what should be happening. However, with a little nudging from TheRedEye, the community started to work together. Some people started tracking inventory, some were keeping track of conversations, and overall, the game started going in a single direction.
Occasionally griefers got the better of the game and, in true forum fashion, would post ridiculous or counter productive commands. Well, perhaps they weren't really griefers. I can remember playing text adventures and trying ridiculous things to see what the parser would say. The advantage to having a human narrator is that even these out of the box commands resulted in interesting things happening. Even the few times that the game ended because of them.
Over all, I am sorry that I missed the chance to participate in this game and story experiment. I whole heartedly hope that they try something like this again. In fact, I'd love to do something like this myself. It has sparked a couple of neat ideas at least. If you know anyone who knows how to write Facebook apps, I'd like to speak with them.
Monday, October 30, 2006
Sam & Max: Freelance Review
Sam & Max Episode 1: Culture Shock is going public on November 1. It has already been live on GameTap for a couple of weeks now. In honour of its pending release to the unwashed masses (and hopefully to its riotous success) I present an homage and a review.
Inauspicious Beginnings
Steve Purcell created these dynamic and slightly deranged characters back 1980, where they made their debut on the campus of the California College of the Arts. By the end of the 80s they could be seen and read in their own full-length comic book. They were then picked up by LucasArts to be turned interactive. By far their most popular venture, Sam & Max Hit the Road released in 1993 to become a cult classic among adventure gaming. Their next stop took them to television land where they found themselves fighting crime, freelance-style, in a Fox-produced Saturday morning cartoon. In 2002 LucasArts announced the long-awaited sequel to Hit the Road, Sam & Max: Freelance Police. Fans were delighted, only to be disappointed by its cancellation in early 2004.
That might have been the end for the Freelance Police. Doomed to obscurity, and kept locked in the hearts and closets of fans and collectors. Fortunately, a clause in the licensing agreement with LucasArts has released them. Without a game released or in production the rights reverted to Steve Purcell. Now Sam & Max are shooting their way back onto the video gaming scene. Steve Purcell has teamed up with Telltale Games, made up primarily of former Sam & Max developers, to bring us more surrealistic crime fighting adventures. One episode at a time.
Inane Questions that Start With ‘W’
Who? Sam is an anthropomorphic dog with a prodigious vocabulary and an over-sized revolver. Max is a hyper-kinetic rabbity sort of thing bent on wreaking havoc and mayhem.
What? They are freelance police, and together they fight crime. They are called up by the Commissioner to tackle the wackiest of situations that the sane of us would not venture near. They dispense justice with excessive dialogue and unnecessary violence. Usually in that order. Right now there seems to be troublemakers down on street-level bothering the neighbourhood businesses.
Where? Inhabiting a world of gritty reality, not unlike out own, our heroes deal with some of the zanier underbelly the city has to offer. The city is a place where both garbage and paranoia litter the streets. The air is thick with fear and smog. Culture Shock conveys this through use of colour and texture in every scene. You get the sense that this is a cartoon, but at the same time you are aware that it is a mirror of life. It also avoids the pitfall of becoming too dark and dangerous, opting for a light-hearted edge to the darker comedy. Culture Shock finds a fun balance between cynical and zany .
Whuzza? The characters you meet help too. A tattoo artist turned psychoanalyst, a conspiracy-minded convenience store owner, and a rash of 40-year-old midget child stars, brings out the surreality that epitomizes Sam & Max. While the game only takes you to a few locations (with some hints at future ones), each is well thought out. Graphical details fill each scene; many of them are even clickable, revealing additional depth through dialog. Thought and care has gone into making the areas you explore both interesting and reusable. The characters are narrow enough to provide instant comedy while allowing for future growth that will keep them fresh. Chances are that we’ll see them all again in future episodes, and there will be new things to look for and learn.
Episodic-ly Delicious
I’m happy to say that Sam & Max fit amazingly well into an episodic format. Admittedly, there is only so much of the rampant banter one can endure. Having a shorter game, complete with satisfying Sam & Max-style conclusion, on a regular schedule will serve to extend the play value over a longer (and more endurable) time. Teaser glimpses provided at the end of the episode will also hook players into coming back, assuming they liked what they got the first time. The plot and flow of the story has been well developed for this format with concessions made for shorter play times, limited locations, and casual players. The game has definite scenes, and while it is strictly linear (all you generative story/multiple paths people can leave now) the depth of character makes it feel as if you are controlling the pace, causing the story to unfold.
Everyone Can Enjoy the Mayhem
As a fan of adventure gaming, I found the first instalment of Sam & Max to be both satisfying, and far too short. I’m used to games that have dozens of puzzles, some obscure enough to require outside assistance, and 10-20 hours of total gameplay. I’m not everyone. Sam & Max clocks in at about 5-10 hours, assuming that you explore all of the wacky and verbose dialogue (which is very well worth it). There is also a complete lack of mindless tasks and incomprehensible puzzles. Getting stuck will mean that you spend a few minutes (not hours!) trying a few very logical, and limited, options. If you get really stuck, jut head over to the official forums for a quick hint or solution.
As a dedicated adventure gamer I’ll admit that many adventure games are simply not user friendly. Oddball leaps of logic, aggravating pixel hunting exercises, and indistinct or indefinite goals (with near unlimited useless objects) are just a few of the things that have haunted this genre and kept it from the mainstream. Telltale Games has done everything in their power to keep these pitfalls far away from their game. The result is something easy to interact with, easy to follow and succeed at, and fun to play.
The most obvious design choice Telltale made was to keep all interaction to a single click. There are no symbolic icons or cursors. There is no confusing verb list. You don’t have to combine inventory items to create some wacky gadget. You point to something, you click, Sam does whatever he needs to do. Sometimes he’ll make a witty remark (with occasional retorts from Max). Sometime he or Max will do something (from the mundane to the bizarre). Occasionally he’ll pick something up to use later. Even driving the Desoto is handled entirely through the mouse and the left-click.
What Stood Up
The episodic format snugs nicely with the story-telling style of Sam & Max. This makes the game feel naturally paced and coherent. It also means that I have five more experiences waiting for me over the next five months.
The game looks great. It’s not photo-realistic, but it is gritty and full of life. The game runs with the cartoony-ness of the world, keeping the lines and colours simple, while allowing a vast amount of detail to sneak in. The game should also remain playable on a wide variety of systems because of the simplicity of the overall design.
The dialog is great. If you have memories of watching the cartoon, then you will enjoy every tongue-twisting and brain-warping syllable. The voice acting is well done, deserving compliments for sounding polished and consistent.
What Fell Flat
While the dialog is plentiful, creative, and pithy the animation leaves something to be desired. The quantity is lacking. After the fifth time that you see Max make the same gesture, you’ll understand what I mean. The game could have used a few more unique animations to pair with the dialog options, or a few more general animations that would prevent us from seeing the same ones over and over again.
Driving in Sam & Max is unnecessarily broken. It is a laudable goal to create a varied experience that pinions on a simplistic interface. However, when fine control is simply abandoned for uniformity then something is wrong. The DeSoto is driven by clicking to the right or left of the car. This leads to slow response, massive over- or under-steering, and a generally frustrating driving experience. Left-clicking on the car should have simply locked/unlocked steering to the mouse movement, leaving Max to drive when you relinquish control to do other things. In any case, this was the part that was most frustrating and disappointing to me. Fortunately it only plays a small role in the first episode.
Case Closed
If you are a fan of Sam & Max, or enjoy a good adventure game (and pine for the days of LucasArts glory), then I highly recommend this game. I know that I will be waiting for the rest of season one eagerly. The game itself is fairly standard adventure fare, with a much lower point-of-entry than many games of this genre. This makes it a good game for casual gamers and those unfamiliar with the rigours of point-and-click adventuring.
I’m not going to rate the games I review, because I find that most review numbers are arbitrary and rather meaningless. I would rather suggest games to people based on what a game offers and what a player expects and wants. Only through matching play-styles to games can you really get a good experience. To that end, Culture Shock is not a game for most hardcore players. Players looking to be told a story in a casual setting are going to be far more interested. This game is easy, linear, not very replayable, exploration-based with almost no action, and friendly to most ages. It also has a very odd sense of humour. Sound like your kind of bullet?